
Irresistible is pretty grim and twisted, something the X-Files has mostly avoided. The show is always atmospheric and creepy, but Irresistible dips into areas best left in the shadows (Chris Carter would get his rocks off doing this every week in the first season of Millennium, which is probably the only show that can match or top the sinister feel this episode and later episode 'Home' manage to pull off). The aspect of death fetishism is, understandably, ambiguous. A lot is spoken about it but the truly dark aspects of it are hinted at in cop jargon or off handed remarks and many of the grisly crime scenes are simply flashed on screen without much focus. For once. . .I'm thankful. When Donny Pfaster sniffs a piece of an underage girls hair at one point, that was enough to make my skin crawl: brief descriptions of his other 'acts' were enough to nearly induce vomit.
This is, in some odd way, a sign of a successful episode. You really want Mulder and Scully to stop this dickbag and, thankfully, they do though Scully goes through some emotional crap as a result. I remember a while back I didn't like this episode because I thought Scully was the anti-Scully. . .a victim needing to be rescued. What I forgot, and was reminded of this viewing, was that Scully has a problem with the idea of death fetishists. . .especially since, as she mentions, they are almost impossible to profile unlike other fetish criminals. In a show that persists in showing anti-human behavior, many scenes in this show that Scully is very, very human. . .and her weakness is no different then Mulder's fear of fire in 'Fire' or his not letting go of his mistakes in 'Young at Heart'. In the end, I respected her more from this episode then anything else.
Because this episode manages to be, amongst many things, about fear. Scully is justfully fearful of what Donny Pfaster represents. This is not only effective in her acting as the audience's eyes (Mulder is quite calm in this episode. . .he even watches football eagerly as grisly deaths are described) but it also helps us realize how close Mulder and Scully are. The writers really managed to sprinkle small character moments into each episode and this episode is yet another barrier broken between the two friends. When Scully cries in Mulder's arms at the end, the friendship goes to another level.

The only gripe I have with the ep is the whole 'manifestation' of evil deal. I understand that Pfaster briefly flashes what other characters perceive as a manifestation of evil (or a bat creature that looks similar to Remans in the film Star Trek Nemesis, years and years later) but when Pfaster morphs into numerous other faces, I didn't buy it. I think the brief glimpses of, what I believe to be, pure evil is enough. The morphing technique was pushing it. But it only lasts a few seconds. . .the rest of the episode is a success in that ironic way: completely uncomfortable and shower inspiring.












